Organiser des Débats Citoyens en Classe d'anglais
Un article de Wiki Agreg-Ink.
(Différences entre les versions)
| Version du 19 mars 2012 à 23:23 Dropscone (Discuter | contribs) (→Exemples de Sujets de Débats) ← Différence précédente |
Version du 19 mars 2012 à 23:27 Dropscone (Discuter | contribs) (→Exemples de Sujets de Débats) Différence suivante → |
||
| Ligne 10: | Ligne 10: | ||
| Les sujets proviennent de : http://www.discip.ac-caen.fr/anglais/news/debating/sujet.PDF / http://espagnol.ac-creteil.fr/documents/ressources-et-usages/2011_debats_citoyens.pdf page 7 / http://allemand.discip.ac-caen.fr/spip.php?article6 | Les sujets proviennent de : http://www.discip.ac-caen.fr/anglais/news/debating/sujet.PDF / http://espagnol.ac-creteil.fr/documents/ressources-et-usages/2011_debats_citoyens.pdf page 7 / http://allemand.discip.ac-caen.fr/spip.php?article6 | ||
| - | • A party can’t be a good party without alcohol. | + | * A party can’t be a good party without alcohol. |
| - | • A wife shouldn’t earn more money than her husband. | + | * A wife shouldn’t earn more money than her husband. |
| - | • All the news is fit to print | + | * All the news is fit to print |
| - | • Being "over informed" enables to be objective | + | * Being "over informed" enables to be objective |
| - | • Cars do more harm than good | + | * Cars do more harm than good |
| - | • Censorship is a necessity, even in a democracy | + | * Censorship is a necessity, even in a democracy |
| - | • Dual nationality should be given to foreigners | + | * Dual nationality should be given to foreigners |
| - | • Ecology is a hypocrisy | + | * Ecology is a hypocrisy |
| - | • Equality of opportunities at school is mere utopia | + | * Equality of opportunities at school is mere utopia |
| - | • European law overrules every country law | + | * European law overrules every country law |
| - | • Euthanasia and murder | + | * Euthanasia and murder |
| - | • Experimentation on animals should be banned. | + | * Experimentation on animals should be banned. |
| - | • Family life is the most important in a child’s development. | + | * Family life is the most important in a child’s development. |
| - | • Famous people can have a private life. | + | * Famous people can have a private life. |
| - | • Fashion contributes to our society | + | * Fashion contributes to our society |
| - | • For or against human cloning? | + | * For or against human cloning? |
| - | • For or against Mc Donald’s | + | * For or against Mc Donald’s |
| - | • For or against organ transplant | + | * For or against organ transplant |
| - | • For or against professional armed forces? | + | * For or against professional armed forces? |
| - | • For or against the death penalty? | + | * For or against the death penalty? |
| - | • For or against the imprisonment of minors? | + | * For or against the imprisonment of minors? |
| - | • Foreigners should be allowed to vote | + | * Foreigners should be allowed to vote |
| - | • Globalization is Americanization | + | * Globalization is Americanization |
| - | • Hitch-hiking is the best way to travel. | + | * Hitch-hiking is the best way to travel. |
| - | • Immigration should be limited | + | * Immigration should be limited |
| - | • Imprisonment is the solution to delinquency | + | * Imprisonment is the solution to delinquency |
| - | • Is the school the only group that should educate? | + | * Is the school the only group that should educate? |
| - | • Is the supremacy of English justified? | + | * Is the supremacy of English justified? |
| - | • It is always desirable to tell the truth. | + | * It is always desirable to tell the truth. |
| - | • It is better to be married than single | + | * It is better to be married than single |
| - | • It is no fun being young. | + | * It is no fun being young. |
| - | • It is possible to be both old and happy! | + | * It is possible to be both old and happy! |
| - | • It’s a good thing to live in a modern city. | + | * It’s a good thing to live in a modern city. |
| - | • Learning foreign languages is essential in today’s society | + | * Learning foreign languages is essential in today’s society |
| - | • Living in a big city is great! | + | * Living in a big city is great! |
| - | • Love is more important than money | + | * Love is more important than money |
| - | • Marriage is an outdated institution | + | * Marriage is an outdated institution |
| - | • Mobile phones are a necessity in our life today. | + | * Mobile phones are a necessity in our life today. |
| - | • Mobile phones are the best and the greatest modern invention. | + | * Mobile phones are the best and the greatest modern invention. |
| - | • Mobile phones limit freedom | + | * Mobile phones limit freedom |
| - | • Money is the most important thing in life | + | * Money is the most important thing in life |
| - | • Money makes happiness | + | * Money makes happiness |
| - | • Music can change the world. | + | * Music can change the world. |
| - | • Nice parents are parents who let their children do what they want.. | + | * Nice parents are parents who let their children do what they want.. |
| - | • Peace at all cost | + | * Peace at all cost |
| - | • People should live together before getting married. | + | * People should live together before getting married. |
| - | • Pour ou contre le don d’organes | + | * Pour ou contre le don d’organes |
| - | • Poverty leads to criminality | + | * Poverty leads to criminality |
| - | • Protecting the environment is the Green Party’s business | + | * Protecting the environment is the Green Party’s business |
| - | • Quotas for French songs on the radio are a good thing. | + | * Quotas for French songs on the radio are a good thing. |
| - | • Rich countries should help under-developed countries.. | + | * Rich countries should help under-developed countries.. |
| - | • School is the best form of education. | + | * School is the best form of education. |
| - | • Scientific research should be regulated. | + | * Scientific research should be regulated. |
| - | • Sharing the same culture and languages is the best way to prevent wars in the future. | + | * Sharing the same culture and languages is the best way to prevent wars in the future. |
| - | • Shopping is boring | + | * Shopping is boring |
| - | • Should a journalist risk his life for information? | + | * Should a journalist risk his life for information? |
| - | • Should athletes taking drugs be penalized? | + | * Should athletes taking drugs be penalized? |
| - | • Smoking should be banned in public places | + | * Smoking should be banned in public places |
| - | • Smoking should be prohibited | + | * Smoking should be prohibited |
| - | • Soft drugs should be banned. | + | * Soft drugs should be banned. |
| - | • Soft drugs should be legalized | + | * Soft drugs should be legalized |
| - | • Sport and money are compatible | + | * Sport and money are compatible |
| - | • The British Empire still rules the world | + | * The British Empire still rules the world |
| - | • The internationalization of mass culture is a threat to our national identity | + | * The internationalization of mass culture is a threat to our national identity |
| - | • The internet is a dangerous area of freedom | + | * The internet is a dangerous area of freedom |
| - | • The life of a public figure should be kept private | + | * The life of a public figure should be kept private |
| - | • The State–and not families_-should provide for the needs of the elderly. | + | * The State–and not families_-should provide for the needs of the elderly. |
| - | • The whole planet is responsible for the greenhouse effect | + | * The whole planet is responsible for the greenhouse effect |
| - | • The younger generation knows best | + | * The younger generation knows best |
| - | • There are things which cannot be. | + | * There are things which cannot be. |
| - | • There is no need to be afraid of the future. | + | * There is no need to be afraid of the future. |
| - | • There should be limits to the freedom of the press. | + | * There should be limits to the freedom of the press. |
| - | • Tradition is outdated | + | * Tradition is outdated |
| - | • TV makes people more intelligent. | + | * TV makes people more intelligent. |
| - | • TV plays a positive role in society | + | * TV plays a positive role in society |
| - | • Violence is the only way to get what you want. No violence, no gain | + | * Violence is the only way to get what you want. No violence, no gain |
| - | • Violence on TV should be banned. | + | * Violence on TV should be banned. |
| - | • Voting at 16 years old. | + | * Voting at 16 years old. |
| - | • Women are born to be Desperate Housewives | + | * Women are born to be Desperate Housewives |
| - | • Women should be treated the same as men | + | * Women should be treated the same as men |
| - | • Women should quit their job after they get married | + | * Women should quit their job after they get married |
| - | • Women should stay at home and look after their children. | + | * Women should stay at home and look after their children. |
| - | • Your school years are the best years of your life | + | * Your school years are the best years of your life |
Version du 19 mars 2012 à 23:27
Définition
Sites Utiles
- Organiser un débating club au lycée :
http://lyceemainedebiran.fr/texte/anglais/The_English_Debating_Club.pdf
- Une vidéo avec des exercices pour s'entrainer au débat:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-7937204747114517138
Exemples de Sujets de Débats
Les sujets proviennent de : http://www.discip.ac-caen.fr/anglais/news/debating/sujet.PDF / http://espagnol.ac-creteil.fr/documents/ressources-et-usages/2011_debats_citoyens.pdf page 7 / http://allemand.discip.ac-caen.fr/spip.php?article6
- A party can’t be a good party without alcohol.
- A wife shouldn’t earn more money than her husband.
- All the news is fit to print
- Being "over informed" enables to be objective
- Cars do more harm than good
- Censorship is a necessity, even in a democracy
- Dual nationality should be given to foreigners
- Ecology is a hypocrisy
- Equality of opportunities at school is mere utopia
- European law overrules every country law
- Euthanasia and murder
- Experimentation on animals should be banned.
- Family life is the most important in a child’s development.
- Famous people can have a private life.
- Fashion contributes to our society
- For or against human cloning?
- For or against Mc Donald’s
- For or against organ transplant
- For or against professional armed forces?
- For or against the death penalty?
- For or against the imprisonment of minors?
- Foreigners should be allowed to vote
- Globalization is Americanization
- Hitch-hiking is the best way to travel.
- Immigration should be limited
- Imprisonment is the solution to delinquency
- Is the school the only group that should educate?
- Is the supremacy of English justified?
- It is always desirable to tell the truth.
- It is better to be married than single
- It is no fun being young.
- It is possible to be both old and happy!
- It’s a good thing to live in a modern city.
- Learning foreign languages is essential in today’s society
- Living in a big city is great!
- Love is more important than money
- Marriage is an outdated institution
- Mobile phones are a necessity in our life today.
- Mobile phones are the best and the greatest modern invention.
- Mobile phones limit freedom
- Money is the most important thing in life
- Money makes happiness
- Music can change the world.
- Nice parents are parents who let their children do what they want..
- Peace at all cost
- People should live together before getting married.
- Pour ou contre le don d’organes
- Poverty leads to criminality
- Protecting the environment is the Green Party’s business
- Quotas for French songs on the radio are a good thing.
- Rich countries should help under-developed countries..
- School is the best form of education.
- Scientific research should be regulated.
- Sharing the same culture and languages is the best way to prevent wars in the future.
- Shopping is boring
- Should a journalist risk his life for information?
- Should athletes taking drugs be penalized?
- Smoking should be banned in public places
- Smoking should be prohibited
- Soft drugs should be banned.
- Soft drugs should be legalized
- Sport and money are compatible
- The British Empire still rules the world
- The internationalization of mass culture is a threat to our national identity
- The internet is a dangerous area of freedom
- The life of a public figure should be kept private
- The State–and not families_-should provide for the needs of the elderly.
- The whole planet is responsible for the greenhouse effect
- The younger generation knows best
- There are things which cannot be.
- There is no need to be afraid of the future.
- There should be limits to the freedom of the press.
- Tradition is outdated
- TV makes people more intelligent.
- TV plays a positive role in society
- Violence is the only way to get what you want. No violence, no gain
- Violence on TV should be banned.
- Voting at 16 years old.
- Women are born to be Desperate Housewives
- Women should be treated the same as men
- Women should quit their job after they get married
- Women should stay at home and look after their children.
- Your school years are the best years of your life
