title

Edith Wharton's
The Custom of the Country
- a footstep that never comes...

"A writer who dares to show up the hollowness of social conventions
must have the courage of her convictions and be willing
to accept the consequences of defying society."

ã Edith Wharton, Expiation.


Agreg préparateurs, maîtres de conf., exam handbook writers/compilers and distance trainers are welcome to browse her and get material for their work.

However, since this cyber effort remains sadly invisible to the eyes of its author's internet-ignorant Académie de Guadeloupe, of which our Recteur loves to 'brag' : "I've got no computer on my desk, I'm a child of Gutenberg"(sic, the printer's heirs today are into computer science, what else?), the webmaster expects visitors to kindly support this grassroot effort done out of his pocket and on his free time by including the site URL in their bibli / webliographies and supercharged univ lectures.

The site address is simply :
http://agreg.fr.fm

Thanks to all those who have been doing so. We are the future.

Merci,

Jean-S. Sahaï

There are two ways of spreading light :
to be the candle or the mirror that reflects it.
ã Edith Wharton, novelist (1862-1937).

-
'Hope not for mind in women; at their best
Sweetness and wit, they'are but mummy, possess'd.'
John Donne, Love's alchemy
-
EDITH
NEWBOLD
JONES
WHARTON
The Duchess of manners,
la rebelle de New-York,
1862 - 1937

-
backward

Wharton's autobiography :

A Backward Glance

"Jêai toujours considéré le monde visible comme une scène de tableaux, plus ou moins harmonieusement  composée, et le désir de rendre le tableau plus joli était, autant que je puisse le définir, la forme que prenait mon instinct féminin de plaire." E. W.

"ÄI have sometimes thought that a woman's nature is like a great house full of rooms: there is the hall, through which everyone passes in going in and out; the drawing room, where one receives formal visits; the sitting room, where the members of the family come and go as they list; but beyond that, far beyond, are other rooms, the handles of whose doors perhaps are never turned; not one knows the way to them, no one knows whither they lead; and in the innermost room, the holy of holies, the soul sits alone and waits for a footstep that never comes." À E. Wharton, The Fullness of Life.

Her Works:
The Valley Of Decision (1902)
The Descent Of Man (1904) (short stories)
The House Of Mirth (1905)
Madame De Treymes (1907)
The Fruit Of The Tree (1907)
The Hermit And The Wild Woman (1908) (short stories)
Artemis To Actaeon (1909) (verse)
Tales Of Men And Ghosts (1910) (short stories)
Ethan Frome (1911)
The Reef (1912)
The Custom Of The Country (1913)
Fighting France From Dunkerque To Belfort (1915)
The Marne (1918)
The Age Of Innocence (1920)
A Son At The Front (1923)
Old New York (1924)
The Mother's Recompense (1925)
Twilight Sleep (1927)
The Children (1928)
Hudson River Bracketed (1929)
The Gods Arrive (1932)
The Buccaneers (1938)
Bunner Sisters
Summer
The Glimpses Of The Moon
The Touchstone

custom cover

Programme officiel de l'agreg interne 2002
3 - Edith Wharton, "The Custom of the Country" (1913)
Penguin Twentieth Century Classics.

_

En français: "Les Beaux Mariages", traduction de Suzanne Mayoux.

      • Laffont, 1964.
      • Coll. 10/18, 1983.

France-Culture : La rebelle de New York Dimanche 22 Juillet 2001 de 17h00 à 18h35 dans UNE VIE, UNE OEUVRE (Télérama n°2688-18/07/01, p.128).

Avec Diane de Margerie, écrivain et biographe de Wharton; Jean Pavans, écrivain et traducteur d'Edith Wharton et d'Henry James ; Elizabeth Lennard, cinéaste et photographe, qui a réalisé un documentaire sur Wharton ; Judith Boullet, productrice de télévision et représentante de la fondation Edith Wharton à Lennox (Massachussets) ; Darina O'Kelly, professeur de linguistique à l'université de Toulon et présidente de l'association Edith Wharton à Hyères.

Présentée par Diane Kolnikoff, cette émission, tout en abordant les grands thèmes plus connus, mettait l'accent sur des aspects de la vie et de l'ouvre de Wharton moins connus...


Qui
en aurait fait l'enregistrement? mer-sea!

Edith Wharton est la grande romancière américaine qui portraitisait la haute société new yorkaise. En fait, c'est la plus européenne des écrivains américains, plus que Henry James, son ami, à qui on la compare souvent. Elle est née à New York, en 1862, dans une famille aisée qui part très tôt vivre en Europe.

Cette expérience a formé son sens de l'esthétique, puis ses goûts littéraires : Tolstoï, Balzac, Trollope, Flaubert et Stendhal figurent parmi ses auteurs préférés. Après un mariage quasi arrangé avec un homme de son milieu, Teddy Wharton, aimant les chevaux et la chasse, mais sans culture, Edith Wharton n'aspire qu'à retrouver l'Europe et adopte la France comme résidence de 1906 à sa mort en 1937.

Edith Wharton publie, relativement tard et timidement, une oeuvre de plus de 40 titres.

Ce que l'on connait moins d'elle, c'est l'étendue de ses connaissances et intérêts. Elle écrit des romans, des nouvelles, de la poésie, des livres sur l'architecture, la décoration, les voyages, la culture française, des articles sur la guerre de 14-18, et des critiques littéraires.

Femme complexe et solitaire, perçue comme «une grande mondaine», Edith Wharton a survécu à des difficultés familiales, au manque d'amour dès son plus jeune âge, à des périodes de dépression, au refus de son milieu de reconnaître sa vocation littéraire.

Diane de Margerie termine ainsi sa biographie:
«Edith Wharton a toujours eu la nostalgie de la symbiose et de l'unité, mais il lui fut impossible de les atteindre, sans doute parce que les blessures de l'enfance avaient refusé de se cicatriser, mais aussi parce qu'elle était persuadée de la solitude essentielle de chacun.

Seule l'écriture pouvait rassembler ses forces et ses faiblesses, réconcilier son désir d'absolu avec son penchant pour la dérision. »

AGREGANT WRITINGS

> comme je n'ai pas franchement aimé "Custom" , j'ai essayé de lire autre chose de Wharton. Et j'ai trouvé mon bonheur avec "Ethan Frome".

J'ai cru un moment que E. Wharton etait une frivole qui écrivait sur la frivolité, quelle erreur! "Ethan Frome" est une histoire magnifique, en pleine campagne !

C'est assez court, je vous le recommande, d'autant plus qu'il y a une introduction très intéressante par Edith W'herself, sur les procédés utilisés. -MC.

Article sur Wharton
dans Le Monde du 6 juillet 2001 - des rapprochements avec Henry James et Walt Whitman.

Site with bibliography, lists of articles...

Discussing the works of Edith Wharton : A FORUM

The organisation of time
in "Custom..." follows the classic chronological pattern with free use of ellipsis & flashbacks but no direct prolepsis although there are foreboding elements or predictions by the characters.

There are passing allusions to S. Brenhardt's American tours & a reference to a copy of Hound of the Baskervilles 1st published in 1902.

So it is tempting to see the opening of the novel in 1903 & little Paul's age is used as a precise indication:

1) Paul is 2 years chapter 14 when Undine forgets about his birthday party.
2) He's 6 chapter 31 when Moffatt helps Undine carry him to a cab.
3) He is nearly 9 in the last chapter so the end of the story occurs in 1913.

However, Wharton herself viewed her story between 1899 & 1906-7 as attested by a handwritten note.

About Edith Wharton

BIOGRAPHIE
extraits: One of the major figures in American literary history, Edith Wharton (1862-1937) presented intriguing insights into the American experience...

EDITH WHARTON, 1862-1937

Born Edith Newbold Jones on January 24, 1862, in New York City, Edith Wharton was from birth a part of the wealthy New York society she depicted so vividly in her fiction.

Through her father, George Frederic Jones, and mother, Lucretia Stevens Rhinelander Jones, she could claim descent from three families whose names were synonymous with
wealth and position: the Stevenses, Rhinelanders, and Schermerhorns.

Educated at home with tutors,
exposed at an early age to the classics in her father's library, Edith Wharton showed early literary precocity.

Although it cannot be said that her parents encouraged her writing, Lucretia Jones recognized her daughter's talent and in 1878 had a slim volume of her adolescent poems (titled simply Verses) privately printed and distributed to family and friends.

By this time, however, Edith had already completed an unpublished novel of some 30,000 words that she called Fast and Loose.

After the youthful trials, Edith for the most part put aside her serious literary endeavors to play the role of a young society lady.

Having suffered through a broken engagement with eligible young Harry Stevens when she was nineteen, Edith in 1885 married Edward R. "Teddy" Wharton, a member of a prominent Boston family and thirteen years her senior.

The couple settled first in New York City, then purchased a home, "Land's End," in fashionable Newport.

In 1902 they moved into "The Mount," their impressively large mansion in Lenox, Massachusetts, with Edith herself contributing to the design and interior decoration.

She had already displayed her talent in this field in collaborating in 1897 with the architect Ogden Codman on

The Decoration of Houses (New York : Scribner's, 1897).

her first full-length published work. Edith and Teddy's marriage, however, was never on a very solid footing.

From the first they experienced intellectual and sexual incompatibility, with Teddy's later neurological disorders adding to their estrangement.

After living apart for many years, they divorced in 1913 when Edith was fifty-one.
They had no children.

Although she never relinquished her American citizenship and made occasional visits to the United States, Edith Wharton lived permanently in France, from 1907 until her death, first in the fashionable Rue de Varenne in Paris and, after World War I, at her two homes: the chateau Ste. Claire at Hyeres and the Pavillon Colombe near Paris.

Here she graciously entertained many of the noted literati of Europe and took great delight in her gardens, which became famous throughout France.

Among her closest acquaintances who experienced her friendship and hospitality were Walter Berry, Gaillard Lapsley, Percy Lubbock, Robert Norton, Bernard Berenson, Paul Bourget, and, most prominently,
Henry James, with whom she discussed her writing and from whom she received much advice.

Still in Paris when World War I erupted, Edith Wharton spent most of the war years organizing various charities for war relief, the most prominent being her two organizations for war refugees, the Children of Flanders and the American Hostel for Refugees.

For her unflagging aid to war-torn France and French and Belgian refugees, she was awarded numerous decorations by the French and Belgian governments, the most noted being the French Legion of Honor.

After the war she continued for many years her aid to tubercular patients in France.

In 1923 Edith Wharton was awarded an honorary doctorate of letters by Yale University for both her contributions to literature and her humanitarian endeavors.

From the publication of her first short story in 1889, Edith Wharton devoted her life to her writing.

During her lifetime she published 22 novels, 11 collections of short stories, 2 volumes of poetry, 4 books of travel or cultural interpretations, an autobiography, 3 other works of non-fiction, several translations, and numerous uncollected poems, stories, or articles.

Although Edith Wharton's novels and stories reveal many themes and settings, those novels which unflinchingly depict New York aristocratic life have won her enduring fame.

Among her most critically acclaimed titles are

  • The House of Mirth (1905), Ethan Frome (1911),
  • The Custom of the Country (1913), and
  • The Age of Innocence (1920), which won for her the Pulitzer Prize.

She is best known as a novelist, but several of her many short stories have been judged among the best American stories of the twentieth century.

Although most of her collections contain stories of note, two that are often singled out as exemplary are early collections:

  • The Greater Inclination (her first published collection, 1899) and
  • The Descent of Man and Other Stories (1904).

A complex woman of her day, Edith Wharton was long before her death generally regarded as one of the foremost American authors of the 20th century, her work admired and acclaimed by many of the leading writers and critics of her time.

The many biographies and critical studies devoted to her life and work give testimony to her enduring reputation, and her surviving correspondence with many leading men and women of letters, as well as her family and friends, gives clear indication of her varied interests and concerns and often includes perceptive comments on her unique world.

Edith Wharton died at her home in Hyères, France on August 11, 1937, at age seventy-five.

Merci à :
Friends of Edith Wharton qui publie

A biography, her papers


"Jêai toujours considéré le monde visible comme une scène de tableaux, plus ou moins harmonieusement  composée, et le désir de rendre le tableau plus joli était, autant que je puisse le définir, la forme que prenait mon instinct féminin de plaire." EW.

Cette sensibilité visuelle, cette recherche de lêharmonie À et la fuite de son contraire, "le désir de rendre le tableau  plus joli" À se retrouvent, au-delà de "lêinstinct féminin", comme les principes directeurs de la vie et de lê“uvre dêEdith Wharton.


*
A propos de l'auteur
*
Repères biographiques
*
L'amitié amoureuse
*
L'ambiguïté de l'innocence
*
Le jardin secret
sur le site de France 3 : Un siècle d'écrivains: E. Wharton

Wharton : biographie

"...as an author's introduction to his work, I can imagine nothing of any value to his readers except a statement as to why he decided to attempt the work in question, and why he selected one form rather than another for its embodiment. These primary aims,the only ones that can be explicitly stated, must be by the artist, be almost instinctively felt and acted upon before there can pass into his creation that imponderable something more which causes life to circulate in it, and preserves it a little from decay ." E. Wharton, intro à "Ethan Frome" (1911).

Quelques articles sur E. Wharton.

Edith Wharton: An overview with biocritical sources

Edith Wharton filmography


A review of
The custom: For money, not love...

The Custom in the Country

Some quotes from Wharton's short story "Expiation" about a woman writer, that sounds quite autobiographical À 

  • "I'm so afraid of being misunderstood,... of being, as it were, in advance of my time ... like poor Flaubert."

  • "A writer who dares to show up the hollowness of social conventions must have the courage of her convictions and be willing to accept the consequences of defying society."

  • "It has always seemed to me that the message I had to deliver was not for myself alone, but for all the other women in the world who have felt the hollowness of our social shams, the ignominy of bowing down to the idols of the market, but have lacked either the courage or the power to proclaim their independence "


Bibliographie
de la Professeure Nelly Valtat-Comet, univ. Savoie.

> Sur le site des Editions du Temps des articles à télécharger sur The Custom of, nous signale Marie de Monaco.

> There are a couple of articles on Wharton on the "Atlantic Monthly" site. They're not precisely on "Custom of the country" but they have some interesting elements that can be useful.

"The Atlantic Monthly" is precisely the magazine in which Wharton published some of her short stories in her lifetime.

Go to
theatlantic.com2001/07/
and
theatlantic.com/06aug/

Edith Wharton lectures plurielles
: texte complet, à télécharger, les Conf. de Nanterre 2001 par un collectif coordonné par Marie-Claude Perrin-Chenour. Ed. du Temps.




THEMES DE REFLEXION :
SKI SE FAIT EN FAC
ET DANS LES STAR ACADEMIES

avec quelques... pistes.

  • Weath and Fame in The Custom of...

  • A la recherche de L'Amérique dans The Custom of...

  • Théâtralité de Custom of...

    pp. 15-16 : Already Undine's chief delight was to 'dress up' in her mother's Sunday skirt and 'play lady' before the wardrobe mirror.

    p. 16 : the joy of dramatizing her beauty

    p; 28 : Undine hated 'scenes', she was essentially peace-loving

    p. 100 : Her face, at such moments, was like a theaater with all the lustres blazing.

    p. 132 : Undine, conscious of the ultimate charm of her mise-en-scene,and the recovered
    freshness of bloom which put her in harmony with it, had never been more sure of her power...

    p. 133 : If she had (...) played with him with such patience and such skill, it was for something more than her passing amusement and inconvenience...

  • Parole et Mutisme dans The Custom of the Country

  • The Custom of the Country, l'oeuvre ambigüe (Reims)

  • La répétition dans The Custom of the Country (Paris)

  • Portrait (s) of Lad(y)(ies) in The Custom of the Country (CAPES Perpignan)

  • Lire et Ecrire dans The Custom of the Country (Paris)

  • Le Désir in The Custom of the Country (Paris)

  • Economy in The Custom of the Country (Paris) :

Value of desire

*a system based on desire value - the self is viewed as a commodity

*irony around the word "business" p247 : if Ralph had indeed viewed divorce as a business he would not have been destitute.

*value depends on the subjective desire of the consumer. p172 : Undine waits for an estimate of the value of her image. lavishing of gifts : arbitrary estimation by men of the value of desire

*Ralph is counterfeit, Chelles is outside the fluctuations of the market.

*child : at first a degradation of her plastic value, then p269 becomes a valuable acquisition

*capitalistic brutality vs 19th century code of morality

*Ralph / De Chelles / Moffatt : system of exchanges, equivalence, a general pattern of circulation, mimetic of financial transactions.

Frivolity of value

*speculations & radical reversals : typical of the patterns of the book

*ventures replace adventures

*pattern of frustration and compensation in the novel

*economic value of reading (??)

*novel offers a stock exchange of prejudices, of values : Undine follows the fluctuations of what she thinks is the current predominant value (divorces Ralph because she realizes that he is part of a devalued world

*the basic grammar of the novel is the comparative - Moffatt develops a grammar of the superlative

*prefiguration of the consumer society and a hint at the notion of regression. superficiality of this age shown in a pattern of obliteration and adjustment

Value of art

*art only becomes central when it is involved in a transaction : literal
connection art-money. Undine sees no art when in Italy, sees only art in St Désert

*Popple only artist. p113 : the picture is merely designed for the room it is to hang in & is a social confection. displacement of the notion of art

*literature is valued : the books in Moffatt's library are too expensive to be read

*general commodification of art. representation of art as convertible into currency vs social recognition vs the elision of real art

notion of speculation, the circulation of meaning

"costum" = history (coutumes) + desire (consommation) + theatricality (costume)


-d'après les notes de GG

  • Ebb and flow - Flux et reflux dans Custom of the... :

> son nom (Undine - onde), les références à l'eau et aux bateaux 'cf. Ralph : "What he most wanted [...] was to learn and to do [...] and then to launch his boat." (p.46 Chap.VI Book One).

des mouvements de flux et de reflux dans la construction du récit avec les "vagues" de nostalgie et de rétrospection (cf. Undine et les souvenirs d'Apex et de son adolescence, les souvenirs de vacances)

Pour les fluctuations, je pense qu'il va de soi qu'il faille se référer aux fluctuations éco., à la spéculation boursière mais aussi aux fluctuations d'Undine, ses hésitations, etc. À Marie
.

  • Le désir dans Custom of the...

- A propos du désir de Chelles

(Il en veut plus après en avoir fait le tour) ou Elmer (Il fait tout pour avoir Undine):

Le désir d'Elmer se situe plus au plan financier (entreprises financières, investissements qui rapportent), social (élevation et changement de classe sociale) et esthétique (l'amour des beaux objets)

Rien dans le texte n'est signe d'un désir , ou une aspiration à posséder Undine, il la connait bien ("He looked at her as if his practised eye had passed through the surface of her beauty to what might be going behind it" p.235) et n'est jamais dupe de ses manoeuvres d'approche.

- Désir chez Undine : désir de reconnaissance,d'être vue, admirée/ fierce dtermination to "get on" in society, inflexible determination to have whatever she wants at once and at any costs.

"Undine's voracious ambitions" (p.180) exemplify the manner and proportions of her desire

("Nothing was bitterer too her than to confess to herself the failure of her power."p.135)

You can't oppose Undine's will :

" What sinister change came over her when her will was crossed? She seemed to grow inaccessible, implacable, her eyes were like the eyes of an enemy" p.96, Book II

egocentric and narcissic :

"If only everyone would do as she wished she would never be unreasonable" ch.XVIII,p.153

cf. Ed. du Temps :
Roman fondé sur l'inaccessibilité du désir :

"All the boxes were full now , but one,just opposite, tantalized her by its continued emptiness"p.38

- Vision rapprochée plutôt qu'éloignée, responsable de l'éternelle insatisfaction (fascination and envy for the "tortoise-shell eye glass" of a lady in the gallery p.57)

- Van Degen's primitive desire can be opposed to Ralph's aesthetic desire (physical refinement) :

"His face was the face of a covetous bullying boy with a large appetite for primitive satisfaction and a sturdy belief in his intrinsic right to them" / " She felt the strenth of Van Degen 's contempt for everything he did not understand or could not buy" ( ch.XIV, at Mr Claud Popple)

whereas, to Ralph,

" the only important thing was that he should live 'like a gentleman' i.e. with a tranquil disdain for mere money-getting, a passive openness to the finer sensations"p.45. "Undine noticed the delicacy and finish of her companion's features. The hand with which he stroked his small moustache was finely finished but sinewy. His skin was as clear as a woman's but pleasantly reddish"p.42

  • Time in The Custom...

The organisation of time follows the classic chronological pattern with free use of ellipsis & flashbacks but no direct prolepsis although there are foreboding elements or predictions by the characters.

There are passing allusions to S. Brenhardt's American tours & a reference to a copy of Hound of the Baskervilles 1st published in 1902.

So it is tempting to see the opening of the novel in 1903 & little Paul's age is used as a precise indication:

1) Paul is 2 years chapter 14 when Undine forgets about his birthday party.

2) He's 6 chapter 31 when Moffatt helps Undine carry him to a cab.

3) He is nearly 9 in the last chapter so the end of the story occurs in 1913.

However, Wharton herself viewed her story between 1899 & 1906-7 as attested by a handwritten note.

  • Frontiers in The...

A) PIONEER SPIRIT

a) Undineês peregrination from Apex to New York or the imperative to go east

–At school, Undine met other girls whose parents took them to the Great Lakes for August; some even went to California, others- oh bliss ineffable! À went east” p. 33

b) Mr Spragg (although he can look rather static) is a pioneer in his own way:

–He stood still in the middle of the room, casting a slow pioneering glance about its gilded void; ”p. 11

c) the call of the wild + reference to gold digging (use of gilt,gilded)

...” the dazzling auriferous world of the Van Degens , the Driscolls and their peers” p. 16

Ä – social gold does not always glitter” p. 218
Ä –two heavy gilt armchairs” –a gilt table” – a gilt basket”
p. 5

Ä Undineês disappointment after the Fairford dinner: –There was no gilding, no lavish diffusion of light”p. 21

The Van Degen place ”where Poppleês portrait of her throned over a waste of gilt furniture”

B) PIONEERS or INVADERS?

Undineês ambition is felt in terms of distance: –something beyond” p.34

Importance of 5th Avenue as a central place : –Beyond the park lay Fifth Avenue and 5thFifth Avenue was where she wanted to be.” P.13

Ä –to be established within the sacred precincts of fashion”p.115

Her ambition is illustrated very early: Ä”hung on the fence with Indiana Frusk”p.15: idea of a boundary to cross.

She disapproves of Mabel because she lacks ambition : –It was all novel and interesting, and at first Undine envied Mabel Lipscomb for having made herself a place in such circles; but in time she began to despise her for being content to remain there”p.19

Vision of New-York as a reservation: reduction of space and narrowing of boundaries :

–He was fond of describing Washington Square as the •Reservationê, and of prophesying that before long its inhabitants would be exhibited at ethnological shows, pathetically engaged in the exercise of their primitive industries”p.45

C) CROSSING BOUNDARIES

- Importance of thresholds:

–Mrs Heeny who crossed those sacred thresholds so familiarly, might some day gain admission for Undine –p.10
Moffatt often appears on thresholds: at the door of the elevator p.75; outside the Nouveau Luxe p.233Ä.

Moffatt can transcend boundaries
–Jove , I wish I could put him in a book! Thereês something epic about him À a kind of epic effrontery” p.146

Ä –this braver of the Olympians”p.145
epic hero, ironical modern Ulysses –He seemed to have nothing to hold back: all the details of the prodigious exploits poured from him with Homeric volume”p.145

–travelling : a way of investigating new territories, of leaving boundaries behind.

Moffatt –They were always coming and going; during the two years since their marriage they had been perpetually dashing over to New York and back, or rushing down to Rome or up to the Engandine” page 325

French aristocracy –As to travel-had not Raymond and his wife been to Egypt and Asia Minor on their wedding journey? Such reckless enterprise was unheard of in the annals of the house! Had they not spent days and days in the saddle and slept in tents among Arabs,”p.288

- Crossing boundaries can also mean a vertical movement: importance of the elevator

Äsoared skyward in the mirror-lined lift” page 68
–At the hotel she asked his number and was carried up the lift”p.319

She often goes up to meet her father, Ralph and Moffatt.

D) OTHER FRONTIERS

- Inner frontiers :

Ralph and his cave : –Once or twice already a light foot had reached the threshold”

–To have stood at the mouth of his cave and have turned from it to the Van Degen lair”p.46

Ralph is unable to find a place to put away Undineês photos (idea of clearing the space in the American wilderness , of setting new frontiers)

”Every corner was packed with the vain impedimenta of living, and the mere thought of clearing a space in the chaos was too great an effort”

- Social frontiers :

cf. the attitude of the Invaders and their disregard of social boundaries ;

–The chaos of indiscriminate appetites which made up its modern tendencies”p45

–Nobody can stop me if I want anything –p.300

- The crossing of these boundaries is a massive attack on the old order

(image of war: –Ralphês adoration gave her such a last refinement of pleasure as might have come to some warrior Queen borne in triumph by captive princesÄ” page 79

–The French world had of course held out longest; it had strongholds she might never capture. But already seceders were beginning to show themselves” page 333.

> Merci à tous pour vos contributions, nouvelle arrivée sur la liste
j'apprécie beaucoup le travail d'entraide qui est mené. C'est en partageant
que l'on s'enrichit, et que l'on gagne...
À Co de Sète.


Wharton, les colloques, la confrontation de nos points de vue
...

De l'ignorance à la connaissance, le chercheur ou l'apprenant passe par une gamme d'émotions dont la première naît de l'incertitude face à l'inconnu, face à la mer d'informations qu'on lui propose pour résoudre ses problèmes... -Claude Gosselin, Information et travail de recherche.

> J'avais entendu dire de la Conférence de Nanterre qu'elle était très passable. Par contre l'ouvrage des Ed. du Temps peut etre une bonne source de réflexions personnelles, même si je l'ai trouvé vraiment peu exploitable. Celui du cned (à mes souhaits, merci) serait bien fait, reste à confirmer ...

En tout cas, je persiste à dire que RIEN ne remplace des lectures approfondies de l'oeuvre elle même. En plus de bien la maîtriser tant dans ses détails que dans ses articulations et thématiques (le contexte socio-historique n'est pas fondamental dans Custom) il me semble important de savoir prendre du recul par rapport à l'“uvre pour pouvoir l'analyser avec une certaine distance.

Et c'est à ça que devrait servir la liste de discussion, car c'est en discutant de tel ou tel sujet qu'on parvient petit à petit à prendre du recul de maniere constructive puisqu'on confronte des points de vue rarement concordants.

Je viens de mettre ceci en pratique lors du voyage dans les jardins anglais organisé par un prof de Paris 4, qui réunissait des optionnaires de Paris 3, 4 et 7, de Lyon 2, et des normaliennes de la rue d'Ulm, de Cachan et de Lyon, qui bénéficient tous/toutes d'enseignements différents (donc complémentaires), auxquels il faut ajouter l'interprétation personnelle des gens avec qui on parle, parce que chacun a sa sensibilité et ne voit pas les mêmes priorités.

Tout ce processus me semble beaucoup plus important que le bachotage souvent stérile d'actes de colloques ou de parutions elliptoïdes & co...

Evidemment, ce n'est que mon opinion personnelle, mais on l'a vu sur la liste l'an dernier avec le travail original de concordance sur Dickens d'un de nos collègues.

Il faudrait savoir ce que vous en pensez, tant préparationnaires de cette année que déjàgrégés. Mais par exemple si on décide de traiter ensemble l'image de la femme, ou le langage, dans 'Custom...' , il faut confronter les points de vue, il faut que chacun dans son coin fasse l'effort d'une réflexion personnelle, et il ne faut pas se contenter de prendre le travail des autres, non pas que ce ne soit pas honnête (on s'en f.ut apres tout) mais que ce n'est d'aucune utilité.

C'est comme de potasser un cours comme si c'était parole d'évangile... Et le mieux, c'est de ne pas être d'accord, of course!

- Lauric Henneton, reçu à l'agreg externe 2001, option B, Paris-Jussieu.

-
NDWM : Lauric a été reçu à l'agreg externe du premier coup en 2001, ses paroles prennent quand-même - avec celles de JM Chavance et Nicolas Nolf dont les utiles recommandations sont visibles en divers points de La Page d'Agreg - couleur et parfum des vents (a)giles!

Liste de discussion agreg-anglais

Réactions :

>
Je confirme ce qu'a dit Lauric, la conf de Nanterre était très passable, on a même eu un prof qui a divagué sur l'opéra! Par contre, les articles de P. Jaworski, de C. Roudeau, de L. Louvel et de B. Montfort sont ceux qui m'ont paru pouvoir nous apporter quelques idées intéressantes.

Cependant, je confirme qu'il est plus intéressant et utile et important de relire les oeuvres plutôt que lire des critiques. - Arm L.


Vous pouvez télécharger la conf/errance de Nanterre: ici

enjoying this ?
Envoyez-nous aussi vos infos !

PAGE D'AGREG - ENTREE

_

OBJECTIFS--
DE LA PAGE


PROGRAMMES AGREG 2001

PREPARER L'AGREG

RAPPORTS
----
DE JURY

-

DIDACTIQUE, ECRIT & ORAL:
EPREUVES

CONSEILS

BIBLIOGRAPHIE

ABORDER
--- LES EPREUVES

WIRED---- DIDACTIQUE BRANCHEE



FACE AU -
JURY

DISSERTATION

LINGUISTIQUE

ART DE LA TRADUCTION

2002
TOPICS

smile

Joyce's
Dubliners

Antony &
Cleopatra

ACCUEIL

Poverty
in Britain

Wharton

Crime

John
Donne

Traductologie

Gulliver's
Travels

Women
In Love



ACCUEIL

DAILY --CARTOON

YOUR COMMENTS

ANGLAIS
AU PRIMAIRE---

COLLEGE ------
& LYCEE


TEACHING KIDS
WEB USE------

PLANS DE COURS---------

INTER-
DISCIPLINARITE
MUSIC -------
& SONG

BACKGROUND MUSIC IN CLASS


SHAKESPEARE
--
EN MUSIQUE


SHAKESPEARE
AU LYCEE?

GRAMMAR
& SPELLING


GRAMMAIRE DE
L'ENONCIATION


---PHONOLOGIE
&
PHONETIQUE

VOYAGES LINGUISTIQUES


ECHANGES
SCOLAIRES ELECTRONIQUES


ASSISTANTS
& LOCUTEURS
NATIFS

GIVING STUDENTS CONTROL LISTENING ACTIVITIES

-TEACHERS AND TECHNOLOGIES

LA PRESSE
EN CLASSE D'ANGLAIS

HEURISTIQUE & CONSTRUCTIVISTE ERE NUMERIQUE


LANGUES ET
TECHNOLOGIE
TEACHING
READING

LIRE DU TEXTE AUTHENTIQUE

ENGLISH CRAZY- LANGUAGE!

INTELLIGENCE & APPRENTISSAGE THEORIE & PRATIQUE


SYSTEME ET EVOLUTION

LE MULTIMEDIA

LE RETRO- PROJECTEUR


LA VIDEO

ESPACES
LANGUES

CROSS- CURRICULAR
,

LES TPE

Hate is too great a burden to share. We must meet hate with creative love. -M.L.King. A.Word.A.Day

PARENTS, TEACHERS, DISCIPLINE

DISCIPLINE CAHIER MAGIQUE

LE CINEMA


ANGLAIS TECHNIQUE ET DES AFFAIRES

USEFUL -- LINKS
THE MARGINAL AND THE
NEEDY

mail

BOEN

SPECIAL -THANKS

dictionary

webring

An E-TEACH member website by Jean-S. Sahaï
[ Previous 5 Sites | Previous | Next | Next 5 Sites | Random Site | Site List]

Ce site expérimental non officiel ne dépend ni... lire cet avertissement.
This independent, experimental site, intended solely as a...
see the disclaimer.

You're most welcome to share your findings,
or contribute your work !

La Page d'Agreg - tiçage Jean S. Sahai Guadeloupe, Antilles Françaises.

Agreg Page - first posting December 1996
© Jean S. Sahaï, 1996-2002 - Guadeloupe, Antilles Françaises.